For any Roofing Project

CONTACT PHONE (267) 243-8039

(215) 689-3545


Mon - Sat 8AM - 9PM


PA • NJ • DE

Metal vs shingle roof: comparing durability, cost, and performance

Posted by Alex Roof

When it comes to choosing the perfect roof for your home, durability, cost, and performance are key factors to consider. Two popular options that homeowners often contemplate are metal roofs and shingle roofs. Both materials offer unique advantages and characteristics that can significantly impact the longevity, aesthetics, and overall value of your property.

In this article, we will delve into the comparison between metal roofs and shingle roofs, examining their durability, cost implications, and performance attributes. By understanding the key features and considerations associated with each roofing type, you’ll be equipped to make an informed decision that aligns with your specific needs and preferences.

Whether you’re embarking on a new construction project or planning to replace an existing roof, join us as we explore the fundamental aspects of metal and shingle roofing. Discover the benefits, drawbacks, and essential factors to weigh when determining the ideal roofing solution for your home.

Understanding metal roofs

Metal roofs have gained significant popularity in recent years due to their exceptional durability, longevity, and modern aesthetic appeal. In this chapter, we will delve into the various aspects of metal roofs, including their benefits, types of metal roofing materials available, and their remarkable durability.

Benefits of metal roofs

Metal roofs offer numerous advantages that make them a compelling choice for homeowners. Some key benefits of metal roofs include:

  • Longevity. Metal roofs are renowned for their exceptional lifespan. Unlike traditional asphalt shingle roofs that may need replacement every 15 to 20 years, metal roofs can easily last 40 to 70 years or even longer with proper maintenance. This longevity translates to long-term cost savings and reduced hassle of frequent roof replacements.
  • Durability. Metal roofs are highly durable and can withstand various environmental challenges. They are resistant to fire, impact, and rot, making them ideal for areas prone to severe weather conditions such as high winds, hailstorms, and heavy snowfall. Metal roofs also offer excellent protection against UV rays, preventing premature fading and deterioration.
  • Energy Efficiency. Metal roofs often have reflective coatings or finishes that help reduce heat absorption. This property allows for better energy efficiency, as the roof reflects a significant amount of solar heat, thereby reducing cooling costs during hot summer months. Additionally, metal roofs are compatible with solar panel installations, making them a sustainable choice for environmentally conscious homeowners.
  • Low Maintenance. Metal roofs require minimal maintenance compared to other roofing materials. They are resistant to mildew, insects, and moss growth, eliminating the need for frequent cleaning and treatments. Periodic inspections and basic maintenance, such as clearing debris and ensuring proper drainage, are usually sufficient to keep a metal roof in optimal condition.

Types of metal roofing materials

Metal roofs are available in various materials, each offering unique characteristics and aesthetics. Common types of metal roofing materials include:

  1. Steel
    Steel is a popular choice for metal roofs due to its affordability and durability. It can be galvanized or coated with zinc or a combination of zinc and aluminum to enhance corrosion resistance.
  2. Aluminum
    Aluminum is known for its lightweight nature, making it easier to install and reducing stress on the underlying structure. It is resistant to corrosion and is an ideal choice for coastal regions or areas with high humidity.
  3. Copper
    Copper roofing offers a distinctive, elegant appearance and exceptional longevity. It develops a beautiful patina over time, adding character to the roof. Copper is highly resistant to corrosion and requires minimal maintenance.
  4. Zinc
    Zinc is a durable and environmentally friendly metal roofing material. It has self-healing properties, which means it can naturally repair scratches and imperfections over time. Zinc roofs can last for more than 100 years and offer excellent resistance to corrosion.

Durability of metal roofs

Metal roofs are renowned for their exceptional durability, making them an excellent long-term investment. Some key factors that contribute to the durability of metal roofs are weather resistance and fire resistance. Metal roofs have high resistance to extreme weather conditions, including strong winds, heavy rains, snow, and hail. They can withstand impact from debris and are less prone to damage caused by inclement weather. Metal roofs are non-combustible and have a high fire resistance rating. They do not ignite or contribute to the spread of fire, providing an added layer of safety and protection for your home.

Exploring shingle roofs

Shingle roofs have long been a popular choice for residential properties due to their versatility, affordability, and timeless appeal. In this chapter, we will delve into the world of shingle roofs, including their advantages, different types of shingles available, and the durability aspects associated with this roofing option.

Advantages of shingle roofs

Shingle roofs offer several advantages that make them a preferred choice for many homeowners. Here are some key benefits of shingle roofs:

  • Affordability. Shingle roofs are generally more budget-friendly compared to metal roofs and other roofing options. The materials used for shingles, such as asphalt or fiberglass, are widely available and relatively inexpensive, making shingle roofs an attractive option for those working within a limited budget.
  • Wide Variety. Shingle roofs come in a wide range of styles, colors, and textures, providing homeowners with ample options to match their preferred aesthetic. Whether you’re aiming for a classic, rustic, or contemporary look, shingles can be customized to complement the architectural style of your home.
  • Ease of Installation. Shingle roofs are relatively easy and quick to install, making the process more efficient compared to some other roofing materials. This can help reduce labor costs and minimize disruption to your daily life during the installation process.
  • Repairability. In the event of damage or wear, shingle roofs are easily repairable. Individual shingles can be replaced without the need for extensive repairs or replacement of the entire roof, making maintenance more convenient and cost-effective.

Different types of shingles

Shingle roofs offer a variety of options in terms of shingle types, each with its own unique characteristics and advantages. Here are some common types of shingles used in residential roofing:

  1. Asphalt Shingles
    Asphalt shingles are the most popular choice for residential roofing due to their affordability, versatility, and durability. They are available in two main types: organic asphalt shingles and fiberglass asphalt shingles. Organic asphalt shingles are made from a base of organic materials, while fiberglass asphalt shingles incorporate a fiberglass mat. Both types are known for their weather resistance and ease of installation.
  2. Wood Shingles and Shakes
    Wood shingles and shakes offer a natural and rustic appearance to homes. They are typically made from cedar, redwood, or other types of wood. Wood shingles are precisely cut, while shakes have a more textured and rugged look. They provide excellent insulation properties but require regular maintenance to prevent decay and ensure longevity.
  3. Slate Shingles
    Slate shingles are renowned for their elegance, durability, and longevity. They are crafted from natural slate stone, offering a sophisticated and timeless look to roofs. Slate shingles are exceptionally durable and can last for decades or even centuries. However, they are heavier and more expensive than other shingle options, requiring proper structural support.
  4. Metal Shingles
    Metal shingles combine the durability of metal with the aesthetic appeal of traditional shingles. They are often made from materials like steel, aluminum, or copper. Metal shingles offer superior weather resistance, longevity, and energy efficiency. They can mimic the appearance of other shingle types while providing the added benefits of metal roofing.

Durability of shingle roofs

The durability of shingle roofs depends on various factors, including the quality of materials, installation techniques, and maintenance practices. Shingle roofs are designed to withstand various weather conditions, including rain, wind, and moderate hail. High-quality shingles, properly installed and maintained, can offer reliable protection against the elements. The lifespan of shingle roofs varies depending on the type of shingles used. Asphalt shingles typically last between 15 to 30 years, while wood shingles and shakes can have a lifespan of 20 to 30 years when properly cared for. Slate shingles, known for their exceptional durability, can endure for 50 years or more.

Comparing durability

When choosing a roof for your home, durability is a critical factor to consider. In this chapter, we will compare the durability of metal roofs and shingle roofs by examining the factors that contribute to their longevity, as well as the maintenance requirements associated with each roofing option.

Metal roof durability factors

Metal roofs are renowned for their exceptional durability and longevity. Several factors contribute to their robustness:

  • Material Strength: Metal roofing materials, such as steel, aluminum, and copper, are inherently strong and resistant to damage. They can withstand impacts from falling debris, hail, and high winds, making them highly durable in severe weather conditions.
  • Corrosion Resistance: Many metal roofs are coated with protective layers or finishes that enhance their resistance to corrosion. This helps prevent rust and deterioration over time, ensuring the roof’s long-term durability.
  • Low Weight and Structural Integrity: Metal roofs are relatively lightweight compared to other roofing materials, reducing the stress on the underlying structure. This characteristic makes them less susceptible to structural issues and can contribute to the overall longevity of the roof.
  • Thermal Expansion and Contraction: Metal roofs have the ability to expand and contract with temperature fluctuations without compromising their integrity. This flexibility helps prevent cracking, warping, and other forms of damage, enhancing the durability of the roof.

Shingle roof durability factors

Shingle roofs, while not as inherently durable as metal roofs, can still provide long-lasting protection for your home. Here are some factors influencing the durability of shingle roofs:

  • Material Quality: The quality of shingle materials plays a crucial role in their durability. High-quality asphalt, wood, or slate shingles tend to be more resistant to damage and have a longer lifespan compared to lower-grade materials.
  • Installation Technique: Proper installation is vital for the durability of shingle roofs. Ensuring that shingles are installed correctly, with appropriate fastening and sealing, helps prevent issues like leaks, wind damage, and premature wear.
  • Weather Resistance: Shingle roofs exhibit varying degrees of weather resistance depending on the type of shingles used. Asphalt shingles, for example, are designed to withstand rain, wind, and moderate hail. Wood and slate shingles, when properly maintained, can provide excellent protection against the elements.
  • Regular Maintenance: Regular maintenance is essential for the durability of shingle roofs. Periodic inspections, addressing damaged or missing shingles, cleaning gutters, and removing debris can help prolong the lifespan of the roof and prevent issues from escalating.

Longevity and maintenance

The longevity of a roof depends on several factors, including the type of roofing material, installation quality, climate, and maintenance practices. In general, metal roofs tend to have a longer lifespan than shingle roofs. Metal roofs can last 40 to 70 years or more, whereas shingle roofs typically have a lifespan of 20 to 50 years, depending on the material and maintenance.

Maintenance requirements also differ between metal and shingle roofs. Metal roofs generally require less maintenance due to their inherent durability and resistance to issues like mold, rot, and pests. They may need occasional inspections for loose fasteners or damaged panels, but overall, maintenance is minimal.

On the other hand, shingle roofs require regular maintenance to ensure their durability. This includes inspections for damaged or missing shingles, clearing debris, and keeping gutters clean. Additionally, periodic treatments or coatings may be necessary to prevent moss, algae, or fungal growth on shingle roofs.

Understanding the durability factors, longevity, and maintenance requirements of both metal and shingle roofs helps in making an informed decision about the ideal roofing choice for your home.

Evaluating cost

When considering a roofing option for your home, cost is a crucial factor to weigh. In this chapter, we will evaluate the cost aspects of metal roofs and shingle roofs, including the upfront expenses, long-term cost-effectiveness, and key considerations to make an informed decision.

Metal roofing costs

Metal roofs generally have higher upfront costs compared to shingle roofs. The cost of a metal roof can vary depending on factors such as the type of metal used, roof size, complexity of installation, and location. Here are some cost considerations for metal roofs:

  • Material Costs: Metal roofing materials, such as steel, aluminum, or copper, can have different price points. Copper, for instance, is more expensive than steel or aluminum. Additionally, specialized coatings or finishes that enhance durability and energy efficiency may add to the overall cost.
  • Installation Expenses: The installation of metal roofs typically requires professional expertise due to their specific installation techniques and considerations. The complexity of the roof design, roof pitch, and access can influence the installation costs.
  • Long-Term Savings: While the initial investment for a metal roof may be higher, it offers long-term savings in terms of durability and longevity. With proper maintenance, a metal roof can last significantly longer than shingle roofs, reducing the need for frequent replacements and associated costs.

Shingle roofing costs

Shingle roofs are generally more budget-friendly in terms of upfront costs. The cost of a shingle roof can vary based on factors such as the type of shingles chosen, roof size, complexity of installation, and geographic location. Consider the following cost aspects related to shingle roofs:

  • Material Costs: Shingle roofs offer a range of materials with varying price points. Asphalt shingles are the most common and cost-effective option, while wood and slate shingles tend to be more expensive. The quality and brand of shingles can also affect the overall cost.
  • Installation Expenses: Shingle roofs are relatively easier to install compared to metal roofs, which can result in lower installation costs. However, complex roof designs or steep slopes may increase the labor and installation expenses.
  • Replacement and Maintenance: Shingle roofs have a shorter lifespan compared to metal roofs, which means they may require replacement sooner. This consideration should be factored into the long-term cost analysis. Additionally, regular maintenance, repairs, and treatments are necessary to ensure the durability of shingle roofs.

Considerations for cost-effectiveness

When evaluating the cost-effectiveness of metal roofs and shingle roofs, it’s important to consider the following factors:

  • Longevity
    Metal roofs have a longer lifespan compared to shingle roofs. While the initial investment for a metal roof may be higher, its durability and longevity can offset the need for frequent replacements, resulting in long-term cost savings.
  • Energy Efficiency
    Metal roofs often have reflective coatings that can help reduce cooling costs by reflecting solar heat. This energy efficiency feature can contribute to long-term savings on energy bills.
  • Insurance Premiums
    Some insurance companies may offer lower premiums for homes with metal roofs due to their durability and resistance to damage from fire, hail, or severe weather events. It’s worth considering the potential insurance savings when assessing the cost-effectiveness.
  • Regional Factors
    The climate and geographic location of your home can impact the cost-effectiveness of different roofing options. Consider factors such as weather conditions, maintenance requirements, and the overall lifespan of roofs in your specific region.

By evaluating the upfront costs, long-term savings, and considering the specific factors that influence cost-effectiveness, you can make an informed decision regarding the most suitable roofing option for your budget and needs.

Assessing performance

When comparing metal roofs and shingle roofs, assessing their performance is crucial. In this chapter, we will explore key performance aspects, including energy efficiency, insulation and temperature regulation, soundproofing, and impact resistance. Understanding these factors will help you make an informed decision about the roofing option that best suits your needs.

Energy efficiency

Energy efficiency is an important consideration for homeowners seeking to reduce their environmental impact and lower energy costs. Let’s examine how metal roofs and shingle roofs perform in terms of energy efficiency:

Metal roof energy efficiency

Metal roofs are known for their excellent energy efficiency. They often feature reflective coatings that minimize heat absorption from the sun, reducing the cooling load on your home. This reflective property can help keep your home cooler during hot summers and potentially lower your energy bills.

Shingle roof energy efficiency

Shingle roofs, especially lighter-colored ones, can also offer some degree of energy efficiency. While they may not provide the same level of reflectivity as metal roofs, certain shingle materials, such as asphalt, can help reduce heat absorption and improve energy efficiency.

Insulation and temperature regulation

Proper insulation and temperature regulation contribute to a comfortable living environment and energy savings. Let’s compare how metal roofs and shingle roofs perform in this regard:

Metal roof insulation and temperature regulation

Metal roofs can be effectively insulated to provide thermal protection. When combined with proper insulation materials and installation techniques, metal roofs can help maintain consistent indoor temperatures and reduce energy loss.

Shingle roof insulation and temperature regulation

Shingle roofs also offer insulation benefits, although not as significant as metal roofs. Additional insulation materials, such as attic insulation, can be installed to enhance temperature regulation and energy efficiency.


Noise reduction is an important consideration, particularly for homes located in noisy environments or areas prone to heavy rain or wind. Here’s how metal roofs and shingle roofs perform in terms of soundproofing:

Metal roof soundproofing

Contrary to common misconceptions, metal roofs can effectively reduce external noise when properly installed. The solid structure of metal panels, combined with insulation materials, helps minimize noise transmission, creating a quieter indoor environment.

Shingle roof soundproofing

Shingle roofs, particularly those with multiple layers or additional insulation, offer good soundproofing properties. The layered structure of shingles helps dampen external noises, such as rainfall or wind, providing a more peaceful indoor atmosphere.

Impact resistance

The ability of a roof to withstand impacts from hail, fallen branches, or other debris is crucial for long-term durability. Let’s examine how metal roofs and shingle roofs compare in terms of impact resistance:

Metal roof impact resistance

Metal roofs are highly durable and can withstand impact from hail, tree branches, and other debris better than shingle roofs. Metal panels are less likely to crack or suffer significant damage, contributing to their longevity.

Shingle roof impact resistance

Shingle roofs, particularly those made with more durable materials like impact-resistant asphalt or composite shingles, can offer decent impact resistance. However, they may still be susceptible to damage from severe hail or heavy falling objects.

By assessing the performance aspects such as energy efficiency, insulation, soundproofing, and impact resistance, you can determine which roofing option aligns best with your preferences and requirements.

In conclusion, the comparison between metal roofs and shingle roofs in terms of durability, cost, and performance reveals important considerations for homeowners.

Metal roofs offer exceptional durability, longevity, and low maintenance requirements. They excel in withstanding harsh weather conditions and provide long-term cost-effectiveness. While they may have higher upfront costs, their energy efficiency, potential insurance savings, and reduced need for frequent replacements contribute to their overall value. Metal roofs are an ideal choice for those seeking a durable and low-maintenance roofing solution.

Shingle roofs, on the other hand, are more budget-friendly initially and can still provide reliable protection for homes. While they may have a shorter lifespan and require regular maintenance, they offer satisfactory performance in terms of insulation, soundproofing, and impact resistance. Shingle roofs are a popular choice for homeowners looking for a cost-effective option with a traditional aesthetic or architectural compatibility.

Ultimately, the decision between metal roofs and shingle roofs depends on specific requirements, budget, climate, and aesthetic preferences. Consulting with roofing professionals and considering factors unique to your location will help guide you towards the most suitable roofing option for your home.